We have Shop Pay!

Make Sure You Join Our Rewards Program!

Make Sure You Join Our Rewards Program!

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Stuffed Animals

Clear filters
Mary Meyer Marshmallow Clyde Cow plush stuffed animal, black and white with gold horns
Mary Meyer Marshmallow Clyde Cow plush toy, black and white spotted, golden horns

Marshmallow Clyde Cow

$34.95

Mary Meyer Marshmallow Max Pup tan fluffy stuffed dog plush toy with floppy ears
Mary Meyer Marshmallow Max Pup plush toy, golden brown fluffy stuffed puppy, side view

Marshmallow Max Pup

$34.95

Mary Meyer FabFuzz plush kittens in orange tabby and gray tabby, lying flat
Two plush cat stuffed animals, orange tabby and gray tabby kittens, on wood floor

Fabfuzz Waffles Kitten

$23.95

Mary Meyer Sparky Puppy plush teether rattle with gray silicone ring
Mary Meyer Sparky Puppy plush teether rattle with gray silicone ring, cream and brown

Sparky Puppy Teether Rattle

$15.95

Mary Meyer Taggies plush cow rattle with colorful ribbon tags and teal teething ring
Taggies Buttercup Cow plush teether rattle with colorful ribbon loops and teal beaded ring

Taggies Buttercup Cow Teether Rattle

$15.95

Mary Meyer Taggies soft baby doll with pink outfit and colorful sensory ribbon tags
Pink striped Taggies Baby Doll with colorful sensory ribbon tags, back view

Taggies Baby Doll

$17.95

Mary Meyer Catsy Kitty plush in orange tabby, black, and gray, sold individually
Mary Meyer Catsy Kitty plush cat stuffed animals in orange, gray, and black

Catsy Kitty

$12.95

Mary Meyer Cooper Putty Pup plush stuffed dog toy, cream and taupe patches

Cooper Putty Pup

$34.95

Aurora 5-inch Max Palm Pals brown plush dog stuffed animal with floppy ears and smiling face
Aurora 5-inch Max Palm Pals brown plush dog stuffed animal with cartoon smile

5" Max Palm Pals

$14.95

Aurora 5-inch Grinch Palm Pals plush toy with mischievous embroidered face, seated pose
Aurora 5-inch Grinch Palm Pals plush toy with yellow eyes and mischievous smile

5" Grinch Palm Pals

$14.95

Aurora 5-inch Cindy-Lou Who Palm Pals plush with blonde hair and red bow
Aurora 5-inch Cindy-Lou Who Palm Pals plush toy with blonde hair and red bow

5" Cindy-Lou Who Palm Pals

$14.95

Aurora 9-inch Who House playset with Grinch, Cindy Lou Who, and Max plush figures
Aurora 9-inch Who House Playset with Grinch, Max, Cindy Lou Who finger puppets and plush house

9" Who House Playset

$45.95

Aurora 12-inch Vintage Max plush dog toy with red collar and yellow bone on head
Aurora 12-inch Vintage Max plush dog toy with red collar and yellow bone topper

12" Vintage Max

$27.95

Light gray plush teddy bear with inspirational message patch on belly, seated upright
Light gray plush bear with inspirational message on tummy seated on wooden chair

Poetic Threads Bear

$41.95

Pink and white fluffy kitten Warmies plush toy sitting upright on neutral background
Close-up of a pink and white fluffy plush kitten stuffed animal with embroidered smile

Pink Kitten Warmies

$32.95

Pink plush highland cow stuffed animal with iridescent horns and fluffy texture
Pink plush unicorn stuffed animal with silver horn and fluffy mane

Pink Highland Cow Warmies

$32.95

Mallard Warmies plush duck with green head, white collar, and brown chest on white background
Close-up of Mallard Warmies green plush fur texture, black eyes, and yellow beak detail

Mallard Warmies®

$32.95

Rainbow tie-dye llama plush toy wearing a gold crown and sunglasses
Child hugging rainbow llama plush with crown and sunglasses, Warmies No Probllama

No Probllama Warmies®

$32.95

Light blue plush puffer fish stuffed animal with textured white belly and small fins
Light blue plush puffer fish stuffed animal with white belly and side fins

Puffer Fish Warmies®

$32.95

Plush Santa Claus stuffed toy with red suit, white beard, and black boots
Plush Santa Claus stuffed toy in red suit with white beard and black boots

Santa Warmies

$32.95

Warmies Red Scarf Snowman plush stuffed toy with carrot nose and twig arms
Child hugging a white plush snowman with red scarf Warmies stuffed animal toy

Red Scarf Snowman Warmies

$32.95

Warmies Statue of Liberty plush toy with crown and torch in teal green fabric
Patriotic teal-green Statue of Liberty Warmies plush with yellow torch and American flag background

Statue of Liberty Warmies

$32.95

Plush rabbit on a soft lovey blanket
Baby holding soft plush bunny in nursery

Bernice Baby Comfy

$21.95

plush toy bunny rabbit
Child hugging Benny the Cuddle Bunny in cozy bedroom

14" Benny the Cuddle Bunny

$18.95

5 inch Larry Texas Longhorn plush with white body brown patches and soft velvety texture
Texas Longhorn - 5 inch plush toy professional product photo

5" Larry the Texas Longhorn

$13.95

gray plush elephant
Child holding Keith Jungle Elephant in jungle-themed nursery

5" Keith Jungle Elephant

$13.95

Warmies Warmies Mouse Warmies for Pets

Mouse Warmies for Pets

$37.95

Warmies Warmies Mallard Pet Toy Warmies

Mallard Pet Toy Warmies

$37.95

Warmies Warmies Brown Dog Warmies for Pets

Brown Dog Warmies for Pets

$37.95

Warmies Warmies Calico Cat Warmies® Junior
Sold out

Calico Cat Warmies® Junior

$22.95

Warmies Warmies Strawberry Cow Warmies Junior

Strawberry Cow Warmies Junior

$22.95

Warmies Warmies Bunny Warmies Junior

Bunny Warmies Junior

$22.95

Load more

Stuffed Animals

Rewards

Join our rewards program and earn $ for shopping with us.

Buy Now, Pay Later

Instalments with 0% interest and no extra charges through Shop Pay

Shop Small

Thoughtfully curated by a small business in Snyder, Texas.

Need Help?

Shopping small means you have real people to help you. Use our chat box or call the store for help.